Follow the Digital Edge on Google
Table of content
Interesting topics
Social Media vs Website: Do You Actually Need Both?
“I’ve got a Facebook page. Why do I need a website?”
We get asked this a lot, and it’s a fair question — not a naive one. A Facebook page is free, it’s where your customers already are, and setting one up takes twenty minutes. A website costs real money and takes weeks.
So here’s the honest answer, including the cases where you genuinely don’t need a website yet.
They do different jobs
Most of this argument happens because people treat these as two options for the same job. They aren’t.
Social media is for being found by people who weren’t looking for you. Someone scrolls past your post about a kitchen you just installed. They weren’t searching for a kitchen fitter. Now they’re thinking about it.
A website is for convincing people who are already looking. Someone types “kitchen fitter Somerset West” into Google at 21:00 because they’ve decided to do something about their kitchen. That’s a completely different person at a completely different stage.
One creates demand. The other captures it. Businesses that do well online do both, and the mistake is thinking one replaces the other.
What social media is genuinely better at
Let’s be fair to it, because a lot of web designers aren’t.
Reach without cost. You can start posting today and reach people this week. A new website takes months to gain organic traction.
Showing work in progress. Photos of a job happening, a before-and-after, a short video of the workshop. This builds trust faster than any “About Us” page.
Conversation. Comments, messages, replies. People can ask a question and get an answer in minutes.
Community. Local Facebook groups in South African towns and suburbs carry real weight. A recommendation in a community group converts better than almost any advertising.
Low barrier. No build cost, no hosting, no maintenance.
For a brand-new business testing whether there’s demand, social-only is a perfectly sensible starting position. Don’t let anyone shame you out of it.
Where social-only breaks down
It works until it doesn’t, and these are the points where it stops.
You don’t own any of it
Your page can be restricted, hacked, or disabled, and there’s often no meaningful appeal process. Businesses lose pages with thousands of followers and no way to contact a single one of them.
This isn’t hypothetical — it happens regularly, usually to someone who did nothing wrong.
Google can’t really send you customers
This is the big one for South African service businesses.
When someone searches “plumber Bellville,” Google shows local businesses with profiles and websites. A Facebook page rarely competes for that search — and that search is someone with their wallet out.
Your Google Business Profile does a lot of heavy lifting here, and it’s free. But it works considerably better when it links to a real website, and the organic results below the map pack need a site to rank at all.
Reach has quietly collapsed
Organic reach on Facebook business pages now sits in the low single digits. Post to a thousand followers and a few dozen might see it, unless you pay.
You built that audience. You now rent access to it.
It doesn’t answer the questions buyers have
A Facebook page is a feed. Someone trying to decide whether to hire you wants your pricing, your service areas, your process, your previous work, your terms. Scrolling eight months of posts to assemble that is work, and most people won’t do it.
It affects what people think of you
Fairly or not, a business with no website reads as smaller and less established. For a R500 purchase, nobody cares. For a R45,000 job, it matters.
AI search is bypassing social entirely
This is new and most SA businesses haven’t noticed yet.
People increasingly ask AI assistants rather than searching. Those tools read websites — structured content, clear pricing, real answers. They largely don’t read your Facebook feed.
If your information only exists inside a social platform, you’re invisible to a growing share of how people now find businesses. That gap is widening, not closing.
What it costs, honestly
| Social media | Website | |
|---|---|---|
| Setup | Free | R3,500–R45,000+ |
| Running cost | Free, or ad spend | R150–R600/mo hosting |
| Maintenance | Your time posting | R550–R2,200/mo |
| Time to results | Days to weeks | 3–12 months organic |
| You own it | No | Yes |
| Found via Google | Barely | Yes |
| Found via AI search | Rarely | Yes |
The website costs more. That’s real and worth being straight about.
What it buys is an asset you control, that works while you sleep, that doesn’t depend on anyone’s algorithm, and that keeps earning for years. Social media is rented attention — valuable, but you stop paying and it stops.
The answer for most South African businesses
Both, with the website as the hub.
Social media creates awareness and conversation. The website is where that traffic lands, gets the full picture, and converts. Email and WhatsApp are how you keep the relationship without a platform in the middle.
Practically:
- Post to social, link to the website
- Website carries the detail — pricing, process, proof, service areas
- Google Business Profile handles local discovery
- Capture contacts so you can reach people directly
That last point matters more than it sounds. If a platform disappeared tomorrow, your list wouldn’t.
When you genuinely don’t need a website yet
Being honest here, because not every business needs one on day one.
You’re testing an idea. Prove people want it before spending R20,000.
You’re hyper-local and entirely referral-driven. A hairdresser with a full book from word of mouth has no pressing need.
You sell exclusively through a marketplace. Takealot does the discovery.
You have no budget for a decent one. A bad website is worse than none. If the choice is a broken free-builder site or a well-run Facebook page, keep the Facebook page and save up.
The signal that it’s time: you’re repeating the same answers in Messenger every week, people are asking where to find your prices, or you want to be found by people who’ve never heard of you.
The mistakes to avoid
Posting nothing but promotions. Both channels punish this. People follow for something useful.
Building a website and abandoning it. A site with a 2023 copyright notice and no new content signals a business that may not exist anymore.
Linking nowhere. Social posts that don’t link to your site waste the attention they earned.
Being on six platforms badly. Two done well beats six neglected. For most SA small businesses that’s Facebook and Google Business Profile — Instagram if you’re visual, LinkedIn if you’re B2B.
Treating WhatsApp as the whole strategy. It’s excellent for conversations with people who already found you. It does nothing for discovery.
The bottom line
It was never really versus.
Social media gets you noticed. Your website gets you chosen. Your Google Business Profile gets you found locally. Email and WhatsApp keep the relationship when a platform changes its mind.
If you can only do one right now, do the free ones properly — Google Business Profile first, one social platform consistently. Build the website when you’re ready to do it properly rather than cheaply.
Not sure whether a website is the right next step? Get in touch — we’ll tell you honestly if it isn’t.
